Harris, isle of extremes: Lingerbay


Last week, I returned to the Isle of Harris and to Lingerbay, on the south-eastern edge of this austerely beautiful island. South Harris seems to exert a strong magnetic pull and draw me back across the Minch again and again – I’ve been coming here since 1986. Some friends think it odd, given that I see this island through my windows on the mainland every day, but I can’t explain it.

Harris is an island of dramatic contrasts and extremes, its west side comprising dunes, machair, sweeping beaches of white sand fronting turquoise seas and long, sweeping rollers from the Atlantic.








As breathtakingly beautiful as the Harris west coast beaches are, what has always resonated most with me is their striking contrast with the more unnerving and unsettling eastern side of the island.

The coastline veers north-east at Rodel and the island reveals a barren and bleak shoreline, with rocky fists of islets thrusting their way up through the waves, like enormous, silent grey seals. As the road curves left and climbs up and away from St. Clement’s Church, it always seems as if we’ve suddenly been transported into a lunar landscape.

Nothing but rock and boulders, some the size of a small car, strewn as far as the eye can see, the bare bones of Lewisian gneiss and the scrubby windswept arms of heather that have been tough enough to survive in this alien place. Carved by millennia of the elements inflicted on this wild, remote isle, nearer to its Canadian neighbour Newfoundland in its character, than anywhere else in the British Isles.




The coastline is dotted with abandoned croft houses, shells of what once must have been much loved homes at one time, before life there became unsustainable.  Harris is an unforgiving place and the people who have populated it have had, of necessity, to be resilient in the face of this wild, rain- and wind-battered environment. Their existence was hard won from scraps of land, leaving little time for sentiment, I’d imagine. Over the years, there became fewer and fewer opportunities for younger people on the islands and many would leave for work or education and never return. 

We fell in love with this ruin at the extreme edge of the bay and its haunting, harsh beauty. Its sense of eerie melancholy drew us again and again to it. Goodness knows what love and effort went into building it, as it is more or less only accessible by sea.







































Each time I’ve stayed in Lingerbay, I’ve been drawn to this house (below), which is right next door to “Mol Ban“, the one we stayed in… perhaps by its stunning outlook and the sense of what a much-loved home it must once have been and the aura of sadness it now conveys. Perhaps by the mystery of how it could have been left to become so ruinous, with the sense that the inhabitants had just stepped out to visit a neighbour and had never returned.

It was fascinating to learn of its history and the lovely family connected with it, who so generously shared their feelings and wonderful memories on a Facebook post of mine about it, last year.

Again, I was reminded of the beautiful Gaelic word: ‘Cianalas’ – kʲiənəLəs – ke-en-alas. I think it is very apt here: “a combination of homesickness, melancholy, and general longing for the place of one’s roots”. The sense of loss and decay in this place which was once a dearly-loved home, was even more overwhelming this year, as the storms continue to take their toll and the bones of the building return to nature.
















The experience of this side of Harris is unsettling, unnerving. It has always seemed a place which embodies the unforgiving nature of the planet and its indifference to our presence here and to our survival as a species. We have a huge impact on the natural world and yet are utterly dependent on it for our own survival. We can’t afford to be indifferent to its thriving, or our days here are numbered.

It’s already looking that way.




10 thoughts on “Harris, isle of extremes: Lingerbay

  1. Clianalas has finally got the better of me, I am heading home to the Bays, to a house that like this one would now be little more than crumbling gables if not for my parents. I tell people here on the mainland that its the lure of my family that calls me home, and don’t get me wrong, I relish the prospect of seeing so much more of them, but the thought of being the one to keep the light on and the hearth warm in the home I grew up in is very very special. The Bays are oft overlooked but once they get into your soul you will always appreciate their stark charm.

    1. Sarah, that’s wonderful – I’m thrilled for you, that you can make this happen. You’re so right, they do seem to be overshadowed by the great sweep of pristine beaches on the other side, but I know exactly what you mean. Best of luck with the move!

  2. 19 Lingerbay was the home of my late husband Charles Mac Cuish grand parents.He spent a great part of his life there he always called 19 home. He spent many years in the Navy but when on
    leave he went ..home..
    The family were all he could ask for

    1. Liz, thank you so much for commenting, it’s much appreciated. I can understand why he would have loved this place and keep returning. It was obviously a much-loved home and a place of special memories for so many family members, who find it heartbreaking to see it left to become so derelict, so ruinous.

    1. Oh Annie, thank you so much. You must go, you’ll absolutely love it, I’m sure! You’ve probably already seen this, but here’s a lovely publication on its geology by SNH and the British Geological Survey: <Oh Annie, thank you so much. You must go, you'll absolutely love it, I'm sure! You've probably already seen this, but here's a lovely publication on its geology by SNH and the British Geological Survey: Fascinating stuff! Hmmm… WordPress won’t let me include the link. Will send separately.

  3. I feel strongly that you, Alison, will and should do paintings of the “ruin’s” window with the wonderful pealing paint. What an awe inspiring place, indeed. And yes, there are many similarities with Newfoundland. The word “windswept” is truly an understatement. The bleakness, itself, Terry and I loved on the northwest coast of Ireland also. Harris is definitely on our list of places to visit.

    1. Ingrid, that’s so kind of you to comment – I do hope you’ll get to Harris some day, it will resonate with you, of that I’m sure. The winds can be unremitting – as they can be over on the NW mainland, with us and it’s something I’ve never been able to get used to. But so much a part of the character of the place and what has made it the way it is. Magical and other-worldly.

  4. Hello Alison, I am a Newfoundlander visiting Harris for the first time this week. I was just saying yesterday how much the landscape reminds me of eastern Newfoundland – bog, rocks and mist. Even the houses built between rocks, the lobster pots, fishing boats – and the wind! The gaelic word you mention – cianalas – seems very apt. Thanks for sharing your photos.

    1. Heather, so lovely of you to take the time to leave a comment! I’d love to visit your province one day…. it has been up there on my list for a long time. Good to have these similarities confirmed by a Newfoundlander – many thanks indeed!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.